After years of waiting, we finally got the Golden Cheese story we've always wanted. And despite all the worries, the story turned out amazing, at least for me.
Warning: This entire post contains spoilers for chapters 17 and 18.
Before the release, everyone speculated that Golden Cheese is a tyrant who was greedy and faked her backstory just to get the cheesebirds to worship her, and the kingdom seems to be less developed than the rest of the kingdoms.
Chapter 17 came out, but to everyone's shock, the kingdom is very cyberpunk ( well this kingdom is the richest after all ), and there are cookie citizens aside from cheesebirds. As the Gingergang explored they eventually found out the kingdom is a virtual world, created by Golden Cheese's soul jam powers. We found out Golden Cheese lost her kingdom during the Dark Flour War, in guilt and grief, she vowed to bring them all back in a world without suffering and war. It is true that she is a greedy queen, but what surprises me is how the story portrays greediness. This word is usually negative, but through out the storyline, it is seen as something positive. Golden Cheese's greed is to protect her kingdom, her people, her treasure, even if she has to trap herself in a sarcophagus and leave the Ancients behind. Her caring and generous (?) side was shown, she loves her subjects and people, she's a way nicer person than all of us thought We should apologise to her for misunderstanding her-. However, how do the Gingergang convince her to join the Ancients if she refuses to leave her Golden City?
Prior to Chapter 18's release, I was worried that the story writers will mess up mid way, just like Dark Cacao arc ( hot take: Dark Cacao arc sucks and rushed, and no it is not a English translation problem ). And in the teaser, it is implied Smoked Cheese is Affogato 2.0, which immensely worried me. I was actually deciding to move back to my Blue Lock alt if the story fucks up, even though the recent Blue Lock chapter is boring me a bit.
Well CRK story writers surprised me again. The reason Smoke Cheese is plotting against Golden Cheese is because that he disagrees with how she is ruling the kingdom, he thinks the Golden City should be expanded instead of being protected and hidden, so that it can be more powerful and fight back all forces. He has good intentions after all, but he kinda got taken away by his own greed. He tolden the citizens that they are all illusions and stole Golden Cheese's soul jam, he even tried to kill her true form to gain full control of her soul jam. This will be quickly solved if she returns to the real world, but the Golden City will be closed down, and this city is the only way her citizens can thrive, right?... Then the Gingergang spoke up, Wizard encouraged her that there will be more information outside of her kingdom to bring her people back to life, Olive and Adventurer promised to not reveal the secrets of Golden City to the public, she now has allies that help to protect what she loved, so that she can find to solution of true happiness for her people ( ok this is one of the few times I don't hate the presence of the Gingergang ).
Golden Cheese finally meets the Light of Radiance, which is the section I love very much. Her light scolds Golden Cheese for refusing to leave her City, thus slowly losing other things she also cared about, like her Cheesebirds from outside world. Her light compared this to holding sand in her fists, it keeps falling out of her hands, yet she refuses to let go and grab onto other things. And what is Golden Cheese's solution? If sand falls out of her hands, she'll just make her hands bigger! She vowed to become more powerful, before she reopens the city, she will gain more strength, so that everything she desires will be protected, so that the sand will not fall out of her hands again. I'm sure this is a metaphor I've heard before, if this is true, the story writer really incorporated the metaphor really well.
Before the Golden City closes down, High Priest Cheesenbird has comforted the people that they won't disappear, but just fall into a long slumber. As the city and its citizens slowly fades away, a child goes to his mother and wishes her a good sleep, which is extremely gut-wrenching. Before you thought all the feels are over, Cheesenbird also tells Golden Cheese to find a treasure in the canyon during sunset. When the cookies arrives, Golden Cheese reunites with the survivors of her kingdom: the Cheesebirds who are taking care of the virtual world. Their ancestor Cheesenbird tolden them to prepare for Golden Cheese's return every sunset in the canyon. As the sunset shines onto the canyon filled with countless cheesebirds, she views her kingdom, proudly and tearfully. Out of all the things in the cookie game, it is the cheesebirbs that make me cry.
In the epilogue, Golden Cheese finally reunites with the Ancients and new allies: Pitaya and the Crème Republic. What's funny and a bit tragic is she likely hasn't known the truth about White Lily yet. I wonder how would Golden Cheese take the news.
I would rate this story 9/10, the only imperfection is I'm not a big fan of how Smoked Cheese is the antagonist of the story, though he has good intentions, he tried to sabotage the kingdom, and I actually think this story does not necessarily need an antagonist. Nevertheless, this story made it to my top 3 favourite Cookie run stories, the rest of them being Operation: Timeguard and Council of the Heroes. Cookie Run stories can be hit-or-miss, I'm so glad this time they made a story so wonderful.
There are a few mysteries unsolved, like how Fettuccine didn't fade away like the rest of the citizens, and why Adventurer got a dream about Golden Cheese. Maybe Fettuccine may be one of the clues to bringing the dead people back to life. Also, the last time a non-soul jam user senses the power of soul jam is Royalberry, who is Hollyberry's son. Does that mean Adventurer is Golden Cheese's son? But that's just a theory, a game theory.